Home

Advertisement

Is there a defining Stargate fic?

  • Jul. 18th, 2009 at 6:41 PM
back to back

I've slid in and out of a lot of fandoms over the years.  Farscape, BSG, Alias, Babylon 5, Buffy, Firefly, and lots of others.  In my experience they all had what I would call a "defining fic" (even though I don't necessarily remember what they all were!).  A story that had seemingly been read by everyone because it was simply that good, that inevitably - guaranteed - would show up any time anyone asked for recs.  They tended to be longer, excellently characterized and superbly well-written (sorta a no brainer, there), and enduring.

So my question, does Stargate have such a fic(s)? 

Because I suspect not, if simply becasue the fandom is so divided.  Nobody ever just asks for "recs," it's always qualified as what kind of story they want - het, slash, none of this pairing, none of that character, nothing in this season.  And if anyone ever does ask for general recs people always seem paralyzed by the open field handed to them and must ask "what kind of story do you want" instead of simply saying "here are the superbly well-written fics I've read."

Don't get me wrong, I understand preference because I of course have my own.  But if someone said to me "this story is achingly beautiful" I'd read it, even if it didn't fulfill my wishlist of preferences.

Preference is not the same as absolute bedrock refusal to read anything that fits criteria x, y, and z.  It seems a shame that there are so many walls dividing such a developed and enduring fandom.

So, is there a defining SG fic?

Tags:

Dumbfounded

  • Jul. 15th, 2009 at 3:19 PM
falling

So I was out and about the other day with my mother.  She wanted to buy some music but, seeing as it's been well over a decade since she updated her music collection and since she doesn't pay attention to artists etc on the radio, had no idea what to buy.  Of course, she protested and said she had bought music recently, some James Last CDs.  And I, having just gone through her records not too long ago (I was unpacking them from the box they'd spent the last...ohh, 13 years in, cause she finally got the record player fixed and we hooked it up), fired back that "buying CDs of music you still have on record is not updating your collection."   Anyway, she ended up with 5 CDs and I don't think I steered her wrong.

But this is not what has me dumbfounded.  As we were standing at the till I noticed a book with the title 11,002 Things to be Miserable About.  Slightly curious, I picked it up and opened it.

It was a list.

That's it, just a list.  Each line had one thing on it, for example "tornados," then the next line had something else and on it went in alphabetical order.

I was absolutely astounded that some publisher out there bought this book.  And then later, as we were eating lunch, I was more astounded by the thought that anyone would actually buy it because... it's a list and who buys a book without opening it??  Perhaps that's why it was 15% off.  I should have checked the publisher because I'm still totally dumbfounded by the thought.  Methinks it might have been self-published. 

Hmm... must check Amazon.
 

Canada Day, SG Fan Awards... etc

  • Jul. 2nd, 2009 at 3:42 PM
ball failure

I haven't posted much here lately!

Let's see, yesterday was Canada Day.  Woot!  I guess.  I didn't do anything, though.  I'm not a huge fan of giant, teeming crowds and the press of bodies in limited space.  Especially when it's hot out, not that it was terribly hot yesterday.  Ok, well, I didn't do anything Canada Day related - I finished pulling up grass in the yard and painted the garage door frames.  Fun.

Hmm, oh!  After what seems like many delays the Stargate Fan Awards have finally opened for voting!  So that's cool.

I've been spending a lot of time watching TV shows I never watched before.  I really got into NCIS (just in time for that killer season 6 finale cliffhanger!) and think it's pretty awesome - better than CSI, the Law and Orders, etc.  Cause it's got the cases and the criminals etc, but it's also just as much or more about the characters.  Also, Ziva David has to be pretty near the top of a list about kick-ass women on the small screen (and I think Cote de Pablo plays her wonderfully - and I can't help wondering how "Cote'" is supposed to be pronounced).

The other big show, West Wing.  Never watched it before.  Am enjoying it, but it has yet to hit me upside the head with that "wow" factor, if you know what I mean. 

The Oilers have been doing a couple interesting things with free agents etc.  I'm shocked and amazed that we signed Nikolai Khabibulin but also, despite how much I liked Roli, excited.

Okay, that was really boring.  Yes, I am a very boring person.

Tags:

People

  • May. 13th, 2009 at 11:41 PM
back to back
Sometimes, maybe a lot of the time, I don't have a very high opinion of people in that general, abstract, non-specific way we mean when we bemoan "why do people do that?!" whatever "that" happens to be.  This attitude of mine has been present for the majority of my life in some form or another, I'd say.

A favourite story in my family is that when I wasn't very old - maybe in the 4-8 range? - I was talking to my grandfather (who would have been in his early seventies).  And he said that I'd have to speak up because  he was old and didn't hear that well anymore.  My apparent response?  "Don't worry, Grandpa, most things aren't worth hearing anyway."   

Indeed.

But aside from the blowhards and outright jerks etc it's unfortunate that people can really suck in worse ways. 

We kill each other over the dumbest things sometimes.  I'm of the rather gloomy view that when the human race inevitably dies out it will be our own fault - whether through nuclear war, or destorying our planet, or whatever.

However, all that said, sometimes when people are being "people", especially on the internet, all it leads to is amusement for me and them making themselves look bad.

Like today, which is what spurred this post in the first place.

I've gotten very few "flames" on my series, especially considering its size; they're always conveniently anonymous so they're fixed with the Delete button.  I got one today and I had to laugh because aside from the profanity and nonexistent grammar etc, their "complaint" was just wrong.  S/he called me a rather uncharitable name in the subject and then said "teal'c?  what about jack?  <repeat profanity>" 

I killed myself laughing because I assume their issue was that they thought Teal'c and Carter were "together."  And as well all know, they aren't.  So, this person took the time to flame something they obviously hadn't read based simply on the character lisiting on fanfiction.net.  Talk about having some issues, not to mention saying more about them than me or my fic.

Though, I've found it to be a common assumption by people that the two characters you can choose to label your fic with denote the/a main romantic relationship.  This is so NOT the case.  It's to indicate the main character(s) of the story.  That's it.  It's not a feature of the site meant to serve ridiculous and juvenile "ship wars"  <gag>.  Yes, I guess often the main characters will end up being together, especially in Stargate, but still...

People.

<shakes head>

Tags:

Crossovers

  • May. 2nd, 2009 at 9:45 PM
losing it FS
I'm speaking of course about fic crossovers. I felt like reading an SG fic since it's been awhile since I've had the time so I went looking...

...and all I found were crossovers.

And not things that make sense. I mean, crossing SG-1/Atlantis, I don't even really consider that a crossover. One universe originated in the other. I was seeing things like SG-1 with Highlander, NCIS, Gundam... something or other, JAG (ok, maybe I could see this one working since they're military lawyers and, minimum, two main SG characters are in the military). And don't even get me started on all the Harry Potter x-overs I've seen.

But in general I. Don't. Get. It.

What's wrong with just a nice SG-1 fic? Why go to the trouble of trying to find a logical, reasonable way for these two often disparate worlds to intersect? Especially when you could just write two separate fics and they'd likely both be better than the single x-over.

I guess it's like taking the SG characters and putting them all in highschool. Or the old west. Or something else totally unrelated. I always see that and think... ok, why don't you just write an original story?

Gahh.

So my search was fruitless.  :(

Tags:

A bit of Canadiana.... hmm, is that a word?

  • Mar. 21st, 2009 at 7:52 PM
tigger
I don't like beer, but I love Molson Canadian's commercials.

The newsest:


The original Joe Canadian:


And in the same vein, Tim Horton's. It's funny only becasue it's Tim Horton's. Any other company I might be offended:


Don't ask me why I felt the urge to share Canadian commercials.

Tags:

Stargate Fan Awards

  • Mar. 19th, 2009 at 1:53 AM
killsave FS

The Way... Series and On the Wings of Bees, Through the Death of Suns were both nominated in the SG fan awards!  Very, very cool.  My thanks to anyone who might have nominated them.

Tags:

Impending Warmth?... Not So Much

  • Mar. 9th, 2009 at 7:24 PM
falling
So it's March and for a lot of people that means they start thinking about spring. Not so much here. In the last two days we got a huge dump of snow, accompanined by blowing wind which always makes neat snow drifts (and whiteout conditions), and the temperatures plummeted again.

Sigh.

Oh well.

A few pics below the cut.

Pics )

That one with the snow hanging over the edge is what happens when things start melting and then freezing again.

Isis Awards

  • Mar. 2nd, 2009 at 7:30 PM
losing it FS

After what seemed like many delays the Isis Awards have finally announced the winners.

The Way... Series won its category of Sam/Other.  Huzzah! 

My thanks to all those who voted!  :-D

Tags:

ROFLMAO!

  • Mar. 1st, 2009 at 12:06 AM
ball failure

I find this quite amusing.  And you really don't need to play WoW to enjoy it, I think.  Just know some internet speak.

killsave FS


I loved Buffy.  I eventually enjoyed Angel.  I mourned Firefly's demise and all the potential it showed in a short 13 episodes.  I waited for and watched Serenity with great anticipation and joy.  And then Joss Whedon left TV for awhile and it was a sad day.

Joss has always excelled at doing what far too many TV shows and most movies still can't seem to pull off.  He's always written strong, interesting, compelling, complex, and flawed female characters.  But not just great women - central women.  Central female heroes.  Because I don't care how great a character happens to be, if I never get to see her for more than ten minutes for every hour episode, if she never gets to get down and dirty, shoot guns, throw punches, disarm the bomb, fly the plane, save the day and generally kick ass then I really don't care that much.  The women I like to watch aren't there to just look sexy, or kiss the hero, or be saved by the strapping man.  They're there to drive the story, to have problems and dilemmas, to get themselves into and out of trouble.  They're there to be awesome.  Joss has always done this and in a genre that has one of the worst track records for having nothing but sexpot women - scifi.

And now he's back.  On Friday, Feb 13th Dollhouse premiered.  It's about people who, presumably becasue something's gotten really screwed up in their lives, volunteer to have their memories, personalities, pretty much everything that makes them themselves erased.  They then get imprinted with constructed personalities to become whatever/whoever a client wants/needs.  After each engagement they're wiped back to a childlike, blank state.  The show is specifically about one such "active" named Echo.  And of course, she starts to remember things that she shouldn't.

It's pretty darn good already.  The pilot was perhaps a little clunky - what pilot isn't, though - but the second episode blew me away in many respects.  Already we're learning backstory, already an arc has been established, already Echo is starting to show signs that something isn't quite working like it should.  She's just a little less blank, a little less... empty.  I already have a bit of anticipation for the inevitable moment when she gets wiped and, instead of there being nothing behind her eyes, there's a person.  Who exactly that person will be is the question.

My only issue?  It airs on the dreaded FOX, famous for screwing shows over.  Two episodes have aired and you can already find people saying it won't last long.  Good God people, give it a chance!  And trust in Joss - I do.  If he gets his way Dollhouse will only get better.

So, if you're looking for a great sci-fi show with that elusive female lead/hero, then please check out Dollhouse.  You will not be disappointed.

Tags:

Rain

  • Jan. 30th, 2009 at 4:50 PM
losing it FS
That's right, rain. 

 

Yesterday.  And not just a little bit, quite the downpour. 

In January.  Almost February.  With a good two or more feet of snow on the ground.

Are you kidding me?  That's just... wrong.

back to back


Battlestar Galactica has had its ups and downs, a few bumps on the way, just like every other television show out there.  But the critical acclaim it has received from everwhere except the television awards shows (with the notable exception of the Peabody) has never ceased.  BSG always excelled at pulling itself up by the bootstraps.  The bad episodes were few and far between and when one aired you could pretty much rest assured that next week the show would deliver.  And pretty much all of BSG's worst episodes were still far and away better than 99% of the mindless trope that's on TV nowadays (read, especially, "reality" TV).

BSG may have spaceships and battles and sentient robots, it may have a bit of a goofy name, but the reason it's so good is becasue it was never really about that stuff.  It's about the characters - always has been and always will be.  It's more of a drama that just happens to be set in space and it goes places some of the most daring dramas don't even dare to go and, certainly, it wades into territory Star Trek, Stargate etc never touched.

The remainder of BSG's fourth, and final, season started today - after far too long of a break, if you ask me - and I waited with anticipatory glee for the episode to air.  I was not disappointed.

WARNING!  If you have not watched the eppy do not read below the cut!  If you've NEVER watched BSG but think, one day, you might, DO NOT read beneath the cut.  Spoliers for the SERIES abound!!

 

Major Spoilers )

 
There's still a lot left to see, a lot of answers and explanations, and I have high hopes that the remainder of the final season will be as phenomenal as BSG's best episodes.  Bring it on!

Tags:

Sanctuary - final thoughts on season one

  • Jan. 13th, 2009 at 4:58 PM
sanctuary
Yes, I know, I totally flaked on all the other episodes.  There were several weeks I couldn't watch until much later and it threw me all out of whack.  But now season one has come to a close and I thought I'd share.  Before I get to Revelations though, my main thoughts on the other episodes.

Requiem - a disappointment.  I think they made a fatal error when they went with the pseudo in media res format.

Warriors - as big of a surprise as Requiem was a disappointment.  At the opening scene I thought every uncharitable thing in the book about getting more cliched, tired trope.  But the Kabal's invovlement saved it and Gregory's introduction was unforeseen (hopefully he'll recur every now and then and they'll tell us, you know, how he's still alive and all).  But Will's God awful Hulk-ish makeup has to be the worst the series has done - I cringed.

Instinct - I don't know the buzz on this eppy but it wouldn't surprise me if a lot of people didn't like it.  I thought it was refreshing and encouraging to see them experimenting with different formats and styles, taking risks, and not getting locked in a formula.  Also, it helped that I already liked the reporter from her role in BSG.

Revelations pt 1 and 2 )

On the whole a pretty good first season.  Generally entertaining, with a few duds for sure but what show doesn't have that?  My hope is that the plotty, arc type suff we got towards the end will continue into and throughout season two (and beyond).  If they'll answer some questions as well, and maybe give us some more flashbacks of Magnus' life, I'll be a really happy viewer.

Until then!

Tags:

Huh

  • Jan. 9th, 2009 at 6:51 PM
tigger

You Scored as Postmodernist

Postmodernism is the belief in complete open interpretation. You see the universe as a collection of information with varying ways of putting it together. There is no absolute truth for you; even the most hardened facts are open to interpretation. Meaning relies on context and even the language you use to describe things should be subject to analysis.

Postmodernist
88%
Existentialist
69%
Materialist
63%
Cultural Creative
63%
Idealist
50%
Romanticist
38%
Modernist
31%
Fundamentalist
19%


I always groaned when the postmodernists came up in any class in University. But the more I think about this the more accurate it seems - well, as accurate as any online quiz can be, that is. But they do offer some degree of amusement.

Brrr!

  • Jan. 8th, 2009 at 4:45 PM
Sassy

This is what it means to live where I do.  One day it's -35 and with the windchill it's -46 and three days later it's -7.  A thirty degree or more jump in temperature either way is perfectly normal, if not highly obnoxious.  I hate the freeze/melt cycle.  But thankfully, since we hit December it hasn't quite gotten warm enough to melt all the snow. 

But I'm bracing for February becasue that's traditionally the month with a week or so of the worst deep freeze - the last few years it was minus forty or more plus the windchill for a whopping minus fifty something. 

Shiver. 

Isis Awards - Voting

  • Dec. 22nd, 2008 at 10:59 PM
tigger

The voting is finally open for anyone who's inclined to particiapte in the awards.  You can check it out here.

Isis Awards

  • Dec. 6th, 2008 at 9:27 PM
wizard

The Way... Series was nominated in the Isis Awards.  These awards are for "rare pairings."  So that's kinda cool. 

But I find it slightly amusing becasue I've always contended quite vehemently that the relationship does not, and should not, define the series.  It's about so much more than which characters do or don't pair off.  Don't get me wrong, I see Carter and Baal as a vital element for their respective characters; but on the whole it's simply a single fact in, what I hope is, a relatively rich tapesrty of details, characters, and diverse elements.  

So I take serious issue with judgements made about the series that are based on this single, minor fact, without knowing anything else and indeed without even reading it.  I mean seriously, what a dumb thing to let control what you decide to take a gander at!  I've never understood the "shipper" thing and I've resigned myself to the fact that I never will.   I guess you'd call this whole issue a peeve of mine - maybe my biggest peeve - for the Stargate fandom.

Anyway, just wanted to share the cool news!

Tags:

The Government... Not the Government?

  • Dec. 2nd, 2008 at 11:02 PM
losing it FS

Usually Canadian politics is really, mind numbingly, totally boring.  But there's been a few developments in the last week or so that aren't so much boring as they are.... mind blowing.

Remember when the Conservatives won a minority government?  Well, the other three parties are pretty ticked off with some of the policies the Conservatives are planning to bring in (and not bring in) to deal with the whole economy thing.  So they've decided they'd have a non-confidence vote and form a coalition government to run the country, negating the results of the election and turning the Conservatives into the oppostion.

Yes, that's right - the Liberals, NDP, and Bloc Quebecois are going to work together.

To say that most people are pissed would be an understatement.

Personally, while I understand why people are mad and fully believe Alberta will get royally screwed should this happen (there's a small chance we could have another election instead), I think everyone needs to take a chill pill and get some perspective.  The facts are these:

1) To the 48 odd percent of Canadians who didn't vote - you don't get an opinion.  You didn't vote, you have no right to now care about what happens with the government you couldn't be bothered to help elect.

2) To the 52 odd percent of us who did vote, stop calling foul and demonizing the Bloc and making ridiculous comparisons to communism - becasue given some of the things I've heard, it sounds like a lot of people don't even know what communism is, except, apparently, the folk boogeyman.  Give me a freakin' break.   The fact is, when Canada elected a minority government, this was the risk we took - that at any time the opposition parites could have a vote of non confidence and topple the government.  It's a fact of our governmental system.  The Liberals, NDP, and Bloc are perfectly within their rights to do what they're doing.

And you know what?  What they're doing is historic.  And given the fact that they're doing this now, when we had a Harper minority government for the last three years with ample opportunity that they didn't capitalize on, tells me that they think they can actually make this work.  It's not a whim, or a knee-jerk reaction, or a power grab - okay, maybe it is a power grab.  But I choose to believe that it's not something they're doing lightly.

So for the love of God, chill out and stop acting like it's the end of the world, for crying out loud.  

At the end of the day this is Canada

Tags:

Sanctuary - "Edward"

  • Nov. 29th, 2008 at 5:28 PM
sanctuary

Although it sucks that we didn't get a new Sanctuary yesterday it was a bit fortuitous because I didn't get a chance to watch last week's until Thursday.  So at least I'm not two weeks behind with my little mini-review.

So anyway, on to Edward.  I thought this was a very good episode.  Why?  Becasue of the character continuity.  In my mind, for a show to really be awesome, it needs one of two things.  Either a plot arc that frames the series (or each season) - like Farscape, B5, BSG, Heroes (though this one's fallen off the rails) - or continuity in the character's lives with their problems, issues, etc - which is what allows me to enjoy shows like Grey's Anatomy.

Spoilers )

If the show maintains its continuity in terms of character development and conflicts I'll be a happy camper.  I hate the "clean slate" approach.

Tags: